Beautiful Virgin Islands

Tuesday, Jun 03, 2025

Belongership Process Compromised! CoI Report Flags Over 400 Recipients

Belongership Process Compromised! CoI Report Flags Over 400 Recipients

The Commission of Inquiry (CoI) report has raised several searching questions about the granting of Belongership status in the territory, including applicants who appeared on a Cabinet list for consideration who did not even apply.

Commissioner Sir Gary Hickinbottom who conducted the CoI, concluded that at least 224 individuals were granted Belongership status, “outside of the framework of the law”, who were “added at Cabinet level based on personal recommendations by Members [of the Cabinet] without any due diligence or process”.

The report notes that there were also 190 persons who did not apply for Belongership but were added to a list and presented to Cabinet. Based on the findings, the CoI report states that there have also been instances where persons were approved for Belongership status but had not been recommended by the Immigration Board, which is a critical part of the requirements.

The report outlines that applications for Belongership is considered on the basis of tenure, measured against a 20-year residence requirement. However, this requirement conflicts with the statutory criteria, and the report points to several inconsistencies in granting Belongership status.

Hickinbottom concluded that the policy has been arbitrarily applied throughout the years, and only through investigations conducted by the CoI, has it been publicised.

The conflicting policy positions relating to Belongership has posed a continuous problem, which has spanned consecutive governments.

“Since 2004, Cabinets of successive VIP [Virgin Islands Party] and NDP [National Democratic Party] administrations have known of this mismatch, and have singularly failed to bring the policy in line with the law, either by requiring the Immigration Department and Board to apply the law or bringing forward legislation to change the requirement to one of 20 years,” the report states.

Although the CoI report clearly states that in order to remedy the discrepancies, a simple legislative change is required, it has not been undertaken. The report also states that there is no existing evidence that suggests that any attempt was made to rectify this issue, suggesting that it has been deliberately unattended whilst the statutory provisions have been ignored.

Process Compromised


Hickinbottom also rejected claims by Attorney General Hon. Dawn Smith that the reason why the criteria used for determining Belongership have not been published is due to lack of capacity within the public sector. He noted that not only is the explanation “simplistic” but there is no existing evidence to support her submission.

Relatedly, the CoI report concludes that there is a lack of internal policy guidance by the Immigration Department and Board while interviewing candidates who have applied for Belongership. The consequence of this is that officials in the Immigration Department adopt a 'subjective approach' to assessment of applications.

For example, the report notes that there is no guidance given to interviewers as to how to conduct and mark an interview as part of the points-based system (which drives interviewers to use their own subjective discretion); no guidance is given to assessors as to how to approach (e.g.) the issue of good character, both in respect of criteria which have “good character” as a mandatory requirement”.

The report notes that this contributes to a situation where the Belongership process is compromised and questionable. Therefore, the report advises that a robust system be administered to ensure that assessors are consistent in managing applications.

Another point of concern is that members of the Cabinet reserve the ultimate power to approve or reject any application according to their own judgement, even with access to limited available information.

Deliberate Move


With the fast-tracking Belongership process, Hickinbottom notes that the problem is compounded since no prior assessments would have been undertaken before Cabinet makes a decision.

Hickinbottom concludes that, “in my view, this has nothing to do with any failings in the Public Service or the absence of a policy formulation unit within government: the evidence suggests that it is a quite deliberate decision by the executive to retain such a discretion”.

Newsletter

Related Articles

Beautiful Virgin Islands
0:00
0:00
Close
Harvard Urges US to Unfreeze Funds for Public Health Research
Businessman Mauled by Lion at Luxury Namibian Lodge
Researchers Consider New Destinations Beyond the U.S.
53-Year-Old Doctor Claims Biological Age of 23
Trump Struggles to Secure Trade Deals With China and Europe
Russia to Return 6,000 Corpses Under Ukraine Prisoner Swap Deal
Microsoft Lays Off Hundreds More Amid Restructuring
Harvey Weinstein’s Publicist Embraces Notoriety
Macron and Meloni Seek Unity Despite Tensions
Trump Administration Accused of Obstructing Deportation Cases
Newark Mayor Sues Over Arrest at Immigration Facility
Center-Left Candidate Projected to Win South Korean Presidency
Trump’s Tariffs Predicted to Stall Global Economic Growth
South Korea’s President-Elect Expected to Take Softer Line on Trump and North Korea
Trump’s China Strategy Remains a Geopolitical Puzzle
Ukraine Executes Long-Range Drone Strikes on Russian Airbases
Conservative Karol Nawrocki wins Poland’s presidential election
Study Identifies Potential Radicalization Risk Among Over One Million Muslims in Germany
Good news: Annalena Baerbock Elected President of the UN General Assembly
Apple Appeals EU Law Over User Data Sharing Requirements
South Africa: "First Black Bank" Collapses after Being Looted by Owners
Poland will now withdraw from the EU migration pact after pro-Trump nationalist wins Election
"That's Disgusting, Don’t Say It Again": The Trump Joke That Made the President Boil
Trump Cancels NASA Nominee Over Democratic Donations
Paris Saint-Germain's Greatest Triumph Is Football’s Lowest Point
OnlyFans for Sale: From Lockdown Lifeline to Eight-Billion-Dollar Empire
Mayor’s Security Officer Implicated | Shocking New Details Emerge in NYC Kidnapping Case
Hegseth Warns of Potential Chinese Military Action Against Taiwan
OPEC+ Agrees to Increase Oil Output for Third Consecutive Month
Jamie Dimon Warns U.S. Bond Market Faces Pressure from Rising Debt
Turkey Detains Istanbul Officials Amid Anti-Corruption Crackdown
Taylor Swift Gains Ownership of Her First Six Albums
Bangkok Ranked World's Top City for Remote Work in 2025
Satirical Sketch Sparks Political Spouse Feud in South Korea
Indonesia Quarry Collapse Leaves Multiple Dead and Missing
South Korean Election Video Pulled Amid Misogyny Outcry
Asian Economies Shift Away from US Dollar Amid Trade Tensions
Netflix Investigates Allegations of On-Set Mistreatment in K-Drama Production
US Defence Chief Reaffirms Strong Ties with Singapore Amid Regional Tensions
Vietnam Faces Strategic Dilemma Over China's Mekong River Projects
Malaysia's First AI Preacher Sparks Debate on Islamic Principles
White House Press Secretary Criticizes Harvard Funding, Advocates for Vocational Training
France to Implement Nationwide Smoking Ban in Outdoor Spaces Frequented by Children
Meta and Anduril Collaborate on AI-Driven Military Augmented Reality Systems
Russia's Fossil Fuel Revenues Approach €900 Billion Since Ukraine Invasion
U.S. Justice Department Reduces American Bar Association's Role in Judicial Nominations
U.S. Department of Energy Unveils 'Doudna' Supercomputer to Advance AI Research
U.S. SEC Dismisses Lawsuit Against Binance Amid Regulatory Shift
Alcohol Industry Faces Increased Scrutiny Amid Health Concerns
Italy Faces Population Decline Amid Youth Emigration
×