British Virgin Islands

Monday, Aug 02, 2021

Supreme Court to review ruling on equality for citizens in US territories

Supreme Court to review ruling on equality for citizens in US territories

The United States Supreme Court on Monday, March 1, 2021, announced it will be reviewing a ruling from the US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit that unanimously found it unconstitutional to deny low-income elderly, blind and disabled residents of Puerto Rico the same access to federal support enjoyed by other Americans living in the states and certain other territories.

According to Equally American, a nonpartisan public interest organization that works to advance equality and voting rights in US territories, in United States v. Vaello-Madero, decided by the First Circuit last year, the United States is seeking to recover $28,081 in Supplemental Security Income (SSI) payments that Jose Luis Vaello-Madero received after moving from New York to Puerto Rico. Altogether, federal discrimination against residents of US territories each year denies billions of dollars in critical support to the most vulnerable U.S. citizens in these areas.

Unconstitutional


The United States is also seeking reversal in two other cases where federal judges have ruled in favour of equality for US citizens living in the territories. In Schaller v. U.S. Social Security Administration, currently pending before the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, a federal district court judge in Guam reached a similar ruling that the denial of SSI benefits to a disabled woman in Guam was unconstitutional. And in Peña Martínez v. U.S. Department of Health & Human Service, currently pending before the First Circuit, a federal district court judge in Puerto Rico ruled unconstitutional not just the denial of SSI benefits, but also the exclusion or Puerto Rico residents from the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (“SNAP”) and Medicare Part D low-income subsidies (“LIS”).

“Equality for US citizens in Puerto Rico and other territories is on the line as the US Supreme Court reviews the First Circuit’s landmark decision ruling that the arbitrary denial of SSI benefits to residents of the territories is unconstitutional,” said Neil Weare, president and founder of Equally American. “SSI is a vital lifeline for millions of low-income disabled and elderly Americans, and there is no basis for arbitrarily excluding citizens living in the territories from this safety net."

With the Supreme Court granting review in Vaello-Madero, President Joe R. Biden and the US Department of Justice are put in an awkward position.


Biden's promise


Last September, then-presidential candidate Joe R. Biden tweeted in response to the US DOJ’s decision to seek Supreme Court review to reverse Vaello-Madero, that, “This ends when I’m elected President.” In fact, the Biden-Harris Campaign made equality for Puerto Rico a central part of his campaign, setting forth in his Plan for Puerto Rico:

According to Equally American, Mr Biden believes that Puerto Rico, and the more than 3 million American citizens who call it home, deserve to be treated with dignity and respect. Whether you live in Reading, Pennsylvania; Kissimmee, Florida; or San Juan, Puerto Rico, you deserve a fair return for your work, an equal chance to get ahead, and a government that treats every American citizen equally and has your back when you get knocked down.

“With the Supreme Court granting review in Vaello-Madero, President Joe Biden and the US Department of Justice are put in an awkward position. Absent the kind of shift DOJ has made in other recent cases, this Administration will in effect be arguing in favour of continued discrimination against the most vulnerable residents of Puerto Rico and other territories,” Mr Weare explained. “This is the kind of case where DOJ should consider reversing its position. After all, it is hard to see how asking the Supreme Court to help collect money from a disabled Puerto Rican man who does not have it is consistent with a pledge to treat citizens in the territories with ‘dignity and respect.'"

Newsletter

Related Articles

British Virgin Islands
×