Beautiful Virgin Islands

Wednesday, Apr 02, 2025

Elton John and Paul McCartney Show Their Ignorance and Selfishness by Spreading Fear-Mongering Over AI Copyright Law Reform

Elton John and Paul McCartney’s opposition to the UK government’s proposed copyright reforms reveals a troubling mix of ignorance and selfishness. These reforms, which would allow AI developers to use publicly available content for data mining unless creators opt out, have been unfairly labeled as a threat to creativity and artists’ earnings. However, their arguments are not only misguided but also fundamentally hypocritical.
AI does not ‘steal’ content any more than a musician ‘steals’ by practicing Mozart or emulating Chuck Berry. Learning is universal—whether it’s a machine or a human being. Machines, just like artists, analyze and leverage existing knowledge to create something entirely new and original. Demanding royalties for this AI learning process is not only inconsistent but utterly impractical. Should every student or aspiring artist now pay royalties to the composers, writers, or educators who inspired or taught them in their early days? This logic is absurd and lays bare the self-serving nature of their argument.

Elton John and Paul McCartney’s opposition to these well-balanced and fair copyright reforms is both hypocritical and absurd. These icons of music built their legendary careers by freely drawing from the vast pool of cultural and educational resources—music teachers, instructional books, and the works of other artists—without ever paying royalties to those who formed the foundation of their success. Yet now, they selfishly argue that AI, a modern tool for learning and innovation, should be denied the same access to publicly available content that they themselves benefited from. Worse still, they seem intent on blocking the next generation from using the tools of their era to build upon the collective knowledge of humanity, just as every generation has done before them.

AI does not copy or profit from their music; it learns from millions of musical sources to create entirely new, original, and creative compositions. Just as Paul McCartney, Elton John, and every other musician produce their own unique music after listening to, learning from, and drawing inspiration from the works of other artists—who never received a share of their profits—AI operates on the same principles of inspiration and innovation. The fact that this process is performed by a machine does not diminish its originality, just as using recording technology to produce albums or streaming platforms to distribute their music—rather than performing live—does not negate their right to profit.

The ability to learn and create original music, inspired by the works of countless other musicians, is an undeniable fundamental human right—one that no law can override, obstruct, or restrict. You don’t need permission to do so. This has been the way of humanity since the beginning: we learn, create, and draw inspiration from one another.

If Elton John and Paul McCartney believe you cannot be inspired by their music to create your own original work, that’s their issue, not yours. By sharing their music with the public, they relinquished the right to restrict others from learning from it and using it as inspiration to create something original.

Innovation thrives on the free flow of knowledge. Blocking AI from accessing publicly available data would stifle progress and contradict the very principles of creativity that these artists claim to champion. Instead of clinging to outdated notions of entitlement, they should recognize that progress—whether human or machine—depends on shared knowledge. Their stance isn’t about protecting creativity; it’s about protecting profits at the expense of progress.

Their fear-mongering does nothing but highlight their unwillingness to embrace the modern world of innovation—a world built on the same shared principles that made their own success possible.
Newsletter

Related Articles

Beautiful Virgin Islands
0:00
0:00
Close
Europe Pursues Digital Autonomy Amidst Transatlantic Strains
OpenAI Lands Unprecedented $40 Billion Funding.
Charity Chairwoman Accuses Prince Harry of Bullying and Harassment
DOGE revealed that USAID provided $84 million to the Clinton Foundation. Of this amount, $3 million was spent on Chelsea Clinton's wedding, and $10 million was used to acquire a lavish mansion.
The State Department has announced the formal closure of USAID.
Apple's Innovation Deficit: Falling Behind in AI and Foldable Technology as Chinese Developments Progress
President Trump Proposes Military Intervention to Obtain Greenland
Passenger Taken into Custody After Engaging in Masturbation on SWISS Air Flight
Barcelona player Dani Alves found not guilty of rape accusations.
PUTIN'S LIMOUSINE DETONATES—SECURITY CHAOS ENSUES
French Foreign Ministry Denounces U.S. Interference in Corporate Diversity Initiatives
Copyright Issues Emerge as AI-Generated Studio Ghibli Images Gain Popularity
This is what we refer to as CREATIVITY.
Removing the Political Opponent Means Dismissing the Remnants of Turkey's Economy.
Malaysia Strengthens Semiconductor Regulations in Response to U.S. Pressure to Restrict AI NVIDIA Chip Exports to China.
OpenAI Launches New Image Generation Tool for ChatGPT
Ex-FIFA President and French Football Icon Acquitted of Corruption Allegations
National Security Advisor Mike Waltz Under Investigation After Journalist Added to Secret Military Chat
Ex-Business Partner of Hunter Biden Discusses Possible Pardon from President Trump
U.S. Attorney General Announces Task Force to Prosecute Government Fraud
American Brands Face Consumer Boycott in Europe Amid Escalating Trade and Political Tensions
White House Investigates Security Breach After Journalist Accidentally Added to Secret Yemen Strike Chat
Samsung Executive Han Jong-hee Dies Suddenly Amid Ongoing Corporate Challenges
German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier has just signed off on a national debt hike to fast-track Germany’s militarization
Heathrow Airport Restarts Services as Investigation into Power Outage Commences
Pope Francis Released from Hospital Following Pneumonia Treatment
Pope Francis Appears in Public for the First Time in Five Weeks After His Hospital Stay
Usha Vance to Head U.S. Delegation During Greenland Visit Amid Discussions on Annexation
Trump suggests US could join British Commonwealth if offered by King Charles
Elon Musk Files Lawsuit Against Jamaal Bowman for Defamatory Remarks
European Countries to Boost Defense Expenditures in Response to Changes in U.S. Assistance
Iconic Boxer George Foreman Dies at 76
European Airline Shares Fall Following Disruption from Heathrow Power Outage
Pope Francis Set to Leave Hospital Following Recovery from Pneumonia
Thousands Take to the Streets in Amsterdam to Protest Racism and Fascism
Revealing the Electromagnetic Characteristics of the Great Pyramid of Giza
President Trump Cancels Security Clearances for Notable Political Figures.
The Development of China's Automotive Sector
Netanyahu Dismisses Shin Bet Chief Amid 'Loss of Trust' and 'Qatargate' Corruption Investigations Involving Netanyahu's Advisors
UK Conservatives Remain Optimistic Despite Polling Challenges
Labour MPs Unveil Initiative to Combat Harmful Influencers and Advocate for Healthy Masculinity
Miami Beach Mayor Cancels Plan to Expel Cinema Following Documentary Showing
Thousands of Drones Illuminate the Sky in Honor of Trump.
Leaders of the US and Ukraine Participate in Constructive Call During Ongoing Conflict
Elon Musk's X Experiences Valuation Recovery to $44 billion.
UK Government Set to Implement Major Budget Cuts in Spring Statement
US Federal Reserve Downgrades Economic Growth Outlook Due to Tariff Uncertainty
EU Claims US Tech Giants Have Violated Digital Regulations
Canada Denounces the Execution of Its Citizens in China Amid Rising Tensions
European Union Moves Toward Joint Debt for Military Spending
×