Beautiful Virgin Islands

Tuesday, Nov 25, 2025

53 years after MLK’s death, George Floyd may not be the ‘perfect’ martyr… but his impact on society could be more profound

53 years after MLK’s death, George Floyd may not be the ‘perfect’ martyr… but his impact on society could be more profound

The anniversary of Martin Luther King’s killing has brought the trial of Derek Chauvin into even sharper focus. While George Floyd was clearly a flawed character, his legacy may prove even more important than MLK’s.
Call it coincidence. Call it poor scheduling. Call it a gift from God. Any way you look at it, the timing of Derek Chauvin’s trial for the murder of George Floyd couldn’t be better, given its powder keg symbolism.

As the courtroom drama surrounding former police officer Chauvin enters its second week, the city of Minneapolis – where Floyd died on May 25, 2020, under the 19-year veteran’s knee – along with America at large and the Afrocentric diaspora, continues to hold its breath on the outcome of one of the most eagerly awaited trials in recent times.

Even by America’s standards, where the killing of black men by the state, each other, paranoid whites and a raft of preventable diseases operates on an industrial scale, the manner in which 46-year-old Mr Floyd was allegedly snuffed out by 45-year-old Chauvin is truly shocking.

I’ve watched some gruesome spectacles in my time on video, from terrorist bombings, to atrocious war crimes, to cold-blooded extrajudicial killings. Such is the life of a hack. But ‘experiencing’ the nine-minute, 29-second slow death of George Floyd, on camera, as police officers stood by without intervention, was grotesque beyond belief. I’ve seen cops pay more interest redirecting traffic than that given by Chauvin’s colleagues for Mr Floyd’s life.

Facing a possible 40 years in jail if convicted of second-degree unintentional murder, 25 years for third-degree murder and 10 years for second-degree manslaughter charges, for the next few weeks, Derek Chauvin will be looking at his jury of eight white, four black and two mixed race peers and praying for mercy. Whether they exact justice, or the streets of Minneapolis deliver their verdict with ‘eye for an eye’ retribution as they did during last summer’s tumult, is yet to be seen.

Last year, George Floyd and Black Lives Matter-inspired demonstrations demanding an end to state-sanctioned racism and police reform were held in over 400 cities across the US; countless other locations in the diaspora quickly followed suit with similar demands. If BLM needed a poster boy to elevate it from being just another ‘radical’ African American organisation to a global rights-based movement, it found it in George Perry Floyd Jr.

Today, the symbolic stakes have never been higher, not just for the US, but beyond. The American criminal justice system needs a metaphorical ‘win’ almost as much as the black diaspora does. As American metaphors go, the nine minutes and 26 seconds it took for Floyd to die under Chauvin’s knee might only have looked worse had he been under the white ex-cop’s grubby boot – or on the end of a rope.

The message in the video that serves as George Floyd’s death mask, coming as it does against a cultural backdrop in which white mass murderers, serial killers, ‘domestic’ terrorists and sundry psychopaths are arrested non-violently is clear: When it comes to the white hegemony, black lives don’t matter one jot. However, as amped up confrontations between lockdown-weary and increasingly angry populations around the world illustrate, whether it’s institutionalised racism or structural equality of any description, the largely non-violent approach of passive resistance, popularised by Gandhi and then Martin Luther King Jr, is once again starting to wear thin. And when that happens, something has to give.

While MLK rightly won plaudits, including a Nobel Peace Prize, his approach came at the ultimate cost. Fifty-three years ago to the day, this week, one of the greatest civil rights movements of the modern era faced the reality of white America’s contempt for its black cousinship when a shot rang out in the Memphis sky. On April 4, 1968, as King stood on the second-floor balcony of the Lorraine Motel, career criminal James Earl Ray hunkered down in a rooming house across the street and fired a single shot from a Remington rifle, fatally wounding the civil rights icon.

In many respects, Ray and Chauvin, and separately King and Floyd, have much in common – aside from the obvious. Like Chauvin, Ray never graduated high school, spent an unremarkable time in the US military and came from a provincial, ‘flyover’ part of the States before dedicating much of his life to lawbreaking, albeit from the other side of the criminal divide. On the other hand, King’s death, like Floyd’s, gave rise to sustained civil unrest during the ‘Holy Week Uprising’ – one of America’s biggest, and most violent post-Civil War demonstrations, with rioting in some 110 cities, the worst hit being Washington D.C., Baltimore, Chicago and Kansas City – all of which led to the deployment of the National Guard in several states with dozens of people reportedly killed.

Both King and Floyd were also complicated, flawed individuals, in their own ways. But then, who isn’t? In 2019, an explosive essay by King biographer David Garrow, published in Standpoint magazine, peddled a serious, unfounded allegation that Dr King may have witnessed and encouraged a rape, aside from having several extramarital affairs – material based on highly questionable FBI ‘intel’. Bearing in mind that the FBI once described King as “the most dangerous black man in America” and suggested he “must be destroyed at all costs,” one should look on such state-sponsored intelligence at best with deep scepticism and at worst as part of a wider calculated smear.

Questioning the veracity of the allegations in the New York Times, Dr Barbara Ransby, a fellow of the Society of American Historians, and John D. MacArthur, Chair at the University of Illinois at Chicago, had this to say about Garrow’s piece of work: “As a black feminist and a civil rights historian, I do not need to be persuaded that many black male ministers during the civil rights era were morally duplicitous, felt sexually entitled and slept around. So, did many Catholic priests, politicians, Hollywood celebrities and some award-winning male academics.” Dr Ransby added, “The lurid and gratuitous sexual narratives that Mr Garrow recounts from F.B.I. edited summaries are reminiscent of the racist manner in which black sexuality has been described historically.”

Within hours of George Floyd’s death, the smear campaign against his legacy, and by association, BLM, had started in earnest. But fake news, salacious memes and police propaganda notwithstanding, there was enough dirt, on the record, including aggravated robbery with a deadly weapon for which he received a five-year prison sentence, to cast Floyd in a very negative light. Bizarrely, a day after George’s death, I received a WhatsApp message from an acquaintance which included a link to an adult site featuring Floyd in a porn movie.

Not one to miss an opportunity to lay into black America, conservative commentator Candace Owens soon released a video claiming Floyd was high on crystal meth when he was arrested. “Everyone is pretending that this man lived a heroic lifestyle,” she ranted. “We [African Americans] are embarrassing... Nobody wants to tell the truth in Black America. Our biggest problem is us. I have no apologies to make. George Floyd is not my martyr. He can be yours.”

As fact-checking website Snopes has pointed out, not all of Ms Owens’ claims about Mr Floyd stand up to scrutiny. But just as the Feds sought to rubbish MLK’s legacy, Owens’ attack on George Floyd’s character raises the question: What makes for a modern-day martyr? Regardless of paths chosen, who are we to judge if someone makes the ultimate sacrifice for the greater good?

Back in August 2011, the same questions were being asked as Britain went up in flames following the police shooting of 29-year-old Mark Duggan in Tottenham, North London. A known criminal and suspected of being in possession of a firearm, Duggan was shot dead by police in a ‘planned operation’ designed to relieve him of said weapon. Some 48 hours after his shooting, an angry crowd gathered outside Tottenham police station, and with tensions between the local black community and local police going back decades, frustration turned to violence, rioting and looting which lasted several days and spread to other parts of the country, resulting in the deaths of five people, over 3,000 arrests and an estimated £200 million in damage.

On paper, Duggan, like George Floyd, is far from classic martyr material. But while the former’s death led to an anti-police and anti-statist rebellion, the latter’s, despite being tainted by scattered outbreaks of violence, has catalysed a groundbreaking, ‘global movement for change’ of which BLM is but the latest and just one component in a struggle going back centuries. Martyrs, like prophets, come in all shapes and sizes. It’s not the content of their character we need judge; what matters most is the impact of their legacy.

In a week where the British government is reeling from the aftershock of its publication of a 258-page report by its Commission on Race and Ethnic Disparities, a report that has been widely condemned as a ‘blackwashing’ exercise designed to absolve the British state of any culpability concerning racism, while pandering to a growing white underclass, Prime Minister Boris Johnson would do well to heed the words of his namesake and former US president, Lyndon B Johnson, who spoke during the Holy Week Uprising.

“What did you expect? I don’t know why we’re so surprised. When you put your foot on a man’s neck and hold him down for three hundred years, and then you let him up, what’s he going to do? He’s going to knock your block off.”
Newsletter

Related Articles

Beautiful Virgin Islands
0:00
0:00
Close
UK Economy Stalls as Reeves Faces First Budget Test
UK Economy’s Weak Start Adds Pressure on Prime Minister Starmer
UK Government Acknowledges Billionaire Exodus Amid Tax Rise Concerns
UK Budget 2025: Markets Brace as Chancellor Faces Fiscal Tightrope
UK Unveils Strategic Plan to Secure Critical Mineral Supply Chains
UK Taskforce Calls for Radical Reset of Nuclear Regulation to Cut Costs and Accelerate Build
UK Government Launches Consultation on Major Overhaul of Settlement Rules
Google Struggles to Meet AI Demand as Infrastructure, Energy and Supply-Chain Gaps Deepen
Car Parts Leader Warns Europe Faces Heavy Job Losses in ‘Darwinian’ Auto Shake-Out
Arsenal Move Six Points Clear After Eze’s Historic Hat-Trick in Derby Rout
Wealthy New Yorkers Weigh Second Homes as the ‘Mamdani Effect’ Ripples Through Luxury Markets
Families Accuse OpenAI of Enabling ‘AI-Driven Delusions’ After Multiple Suicides
UK Unveils Critical-Minerals Strategy to Break China Supply-Chain Grip
Taylor Swift’s “The Fate of Ophelia” Extends U.K. No. 1 Run to Five Weeks
UK VPN Sign-Ups Surge by Over 1,400 % as Age-Verification Law Takes Effect
Former MEP Nathan Gill Jailed for Over Ten Years After Taking Pro-Russia Bribes
Majority of UK Entrepreneurs Regard Government as ‘Anti-Business’, Survey Shows
UK’s Starmer and US President Trump Align as Geneva Talks Probe Ukraine Peace Plan
UK Prime Minister Signals Former Prince Andrew Should Testify to US Epstein Inquiry
Royal Navy Deploys HMS Severn to Shadow Russian Corvette and Tanker Off UK Coast
China’s Wedding Boom: Nightclubs, Mountains and a Demographic Reset
Fugees Founding Member Pras Michel Sentenced to 14 Years in High-Profile US Foreign Influence Case
WhatsApp’s Unexpected Rise Reshapes American Messaging Habits
United States: Judge Dressed Up as Elvis During Hearings – and Was Forced to Resign
Johnson Blasts ‘Incoherent’ Covid Inquiry Findings Amid Report’s Harsh Critique of His Government
Lord Rothermere Secures £500 Million Deal to Acquire Telegraph Titles
Maduro Tightens Security Measures as U.S. Strike Threat Intensifies
U.S. Envoys Deliver Ultimatum to Ukraine: Sign Peace Deal by Thursday or Risk Losing American Support
Zelenskyy Signals Progress Toward Ending the War: ‘One of the Hardest Moments in History’ (end of his business model?)
U.S. Issues Alert Declaring Venezuelan Airspace a Hazard Due to Escalating Security Conditions
The U.S. State Department Announces That Mass Migration Constitutes an Existential Threat to Western Civilization and Undermines the Stability of Key American Allies
Students Challenge AI-Driven Teaching at University of Staffordshire
Pikeville Medical Center Partners with UK’s Golisano Children’s Network to Expand Pediatric Care
Germany, France and UK Confirm Full Support for Ukraine in US-Backed Security Plan
UK Low-Traffic Neighbourhoods Face Rising Backlash as Pandemic Schemes Unravel
UK Records Coldest Night of Autumn as Sub-Zero Conditions Sweep the Country
UK at Risk of Losing International Doctors as Workforce Exodus Grows, Regulator Warns
ASU Launches ASU London, Extending Its Innovation Brand to the UK Education Market
UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer to Visit China in January as Diplomatic Reset Accelerates
Google Launches Voluntary Buyouts for UK Staff Amid AI-Driven Company Realignment
UK braces for freezing snap as snow and ice warnings escalate
Majority of UK Novelists Fear AI Could Displace Their Work, Cambridge Study Finds
UK's Carrier Strike Group Achieves Full Operational Capability During NATO Drill in Mediterranean
Trump and Mamdani to Meet at the White House: “The Communist Asked”
Nvidia Again Beats Forecasts, Shares Jump in After-Hours Trading
Wintry Conditions Persist Along UK Coasts After Up to Seven Centimetres of Snow
UK Inflation Eases to 3.6 % in October, Opening Door for Rate Cut
UK Accelerates Munitions Factory Build-Out to Reinforce Warfighting Readiness
UK Consumer Optimism Plunges Ahead of November Budget
A Decade of Innovation Stagnation at Apple: The Cook Era Critique
×