Beautiful Virgin Islands

Elizabeth Warren’s new crypto bill sent shockwaves through the industry. Here’s what it could mean

Elizabeth Warren’s new crypto bill sent shockwaves through the industry. Here’s what it could mean

The money laundering-focused legislation could change the entire ecosystem.

On Dec. 14, as the Senate Banking Committee held a hearing on the collapse of FTX, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) was late to take her seat.

As one of the highest-profile members of the committee—and an outspoken critic of crypto—it seemed unlikely she would miss the event, with witnesses including celebrity investor Kevin O’Leary and TV-star-turned-crypto-critic Ben McKenzie.

A flurry of legislative activity may have caused her delay. Earlier that day, Warren introduced a bill with Sen. Roger Marshall (R-Kans.) called the “Digital Asset Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2022,” which aims to increase financial requirements for crypto.

When Warren eventually took her seat at the hearing, her remarks were not about FTX, but instead the focus of her bill: the ways that crypto facilitates global crime.

“Crypto has become the preferred tool for terrorists, for ransomware gangs, for drug dealers, or rogue states that want to launder money,” she said.

Her bill drew immediate pushback from the industry, with the think tank Coin Center publishing a rebuttal describing it as “the most direct attack on the personal freedom and privacy of cryptocurrency users and developers we’ve yet seen.”

“Through our entire financial system, we operate on a principle that says: same kind of transaction, same kind of risks, same set of rules,” a Warren spokesperson told Fortune. “There is no reason that cryptocurrencies should be held to a lower standard that creates loopholes for criminals to launder money and finance terrorism.”

The crux of the bill brings know-your-customer rules to different players in the ecosystem—including wallet providers, miners, and node operators—and prohibits financial institutions from using privacy tools such as Tornado Cash and Monero.

Patrick Daugherty a lawyer who directs the digital assets and Web3 practice at Foley & Lardner, and teaches at Cornell Law School, discussed the pros and cons of the bill with Fortune.

On the positive side, it empowers federal financial regulatory agencies including the Treasury Department, the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to audit “money services businesses” for compliance.

Given the failure of FTX, Daugherty described this as the “one correct step to make,” just as the Bernie Madoff scandal created a new unit within the SEC to audit investment advisers.

On the negative side, Daugherty said that the bill overreaches in its definition of what constitutes a “money service business.” For Warren and Marshall, this could include miners, validators, and even wallet providers. As Daugherty pointed out, that could mean hardware manufacturers like Ledger.

Under the bill, these entities would have to identify customers and track their transactions, ensuring their compliance with anti-money laundering programs.

For Daugherty, banning privacy tools is a mixed bag. After the Treasury Department’s crackdown on Tornado Cash in August, regulatory clarity is desperately needed, but a total prohibition may go too far.

What’s the opposition?

Warren has long been a bogeyman for the crypto industry. Her recent bill isn’t even the first this year seeking to crack down on crypto’s role in money laundering. In March, she introduced a bill aimed at bolstering sanctions against Russia through imposing restrictions on the broader crypto ecosystem, which critics similarly called an overreach.

Coin Center’s Peter Van Valkenburgh described the recent bill as unconstitutional in two regards. The anti-privacy measures, he wrote, would violate the First Amendment by making it impossible for users to make anonymous payments, including political donations. And the bill may be deemed unconstitutional under the Fourth Amendment by “deputizing” software developers and miners to collect and report private information with a warrant.

In the bigger picture, the bill repudiates many of the core tenets of cryptocurrency—reducing the privacy elements of the ecosystem and treating its “decentralized” participants, such as miners and node operators, as centralized figures responsible for a network’s actions.

As Daugherty told Fortune, these elements of the bill could be viewed as either a bug or a feature.

“If you don't trust crypto assets at all, or if you have some philosophical opposition to them," he said, “then you will probably regard these as features.”

What's the upside?

Hilary Allen, a law professor at American University and one of the witnesses at the Senate Banking hearing last week, said that the bill closes loopholes created by crypto.

“There’s this sense in the space that technology is entirely detached from any human activity,” she told Fortune. “Software is written by people, and technology is administered by people.”

Even though advocates may argue that participants like wallet providers and validators aren't linked to transactions, Allen said they shouldn't be exempt from money laundering laws.

“If you create a technology loophole in the law, then everybody will exploit that loophole,” she added.

Allen's views reflect a skepticism that groups within the crypto ecosystem are truly decentralized—some miners, for instance, are large companies.

Crypto skeptics in Congress have said they want to ensure crypto doesn’t become intertwined with the traditional financial system, a trend that has already begun with institutions like BNY Mellon moving into the space. Allen said strict anti-money laundering laws imposed on the broader crypto ecosystem could keep it separated from traditional finance.

What about legal challenges?

“It’s unsurprising that the crypto industry is making meritless legal arguments to deflect responsibility to follow common sense anti-money laundering rules,” said the Warren spokesperson.

Allen similarly described Coin Center’s argument as “self-serving,” but there is still the open question of what would happen if the bill became law and was challenged in the court system.

With the Supreme Court’s rightward shift, there is a heavy cloud hanging over the administrative state. In this year’s landmark West Virginia v. Enviromental Protection Agency case, the Supreme Court restricted the ability of federal agencies to regulate based on congressional authorization.

If the digital assets bill became law, it would be an actual statute, not just agency action. Even so, as Allen told Fortune, the agencies would have to engage in interpretation to implement the law, which would likely end up challenged in court.

What's next?

Warren and Marshall introduced the bill into the Senate Banking Committee with the intention to re-introduce the bill during the next congressional session beginning in January.

“Senator Warren will continue working in the next Congress to pass this bipartisan legislation into law,” said the Warren spokesperson.

The bill will join a crowded field of crypto legislation. Rather than putting investor protection against free market ideals, Allen said the bill could draw bipartisan support by focusing on national security. She described it as “low-hanging fruit.”

“It’s allowed common cause to be made here,” she told Fortune.


Related Articles

Beautiful Virgin Islands
Jeremy Hunt Accused of Exaggerating Conservatives' Economic Record
I have a dream, MLK inspiring speech
Dublin and Monaghan Bombings 50th Anniversary: Calls for Justice
Aretha Franklin, Marvis Staples - Oh Happy Day
Rishi Sunak and Akshata Murty’s Wealth Rises to £651 Million
BVI Freedom Song
New Caledonia Riots Escalate After French Voting Rights Change
Billy Preston - You Can't Beat God Giving (Live)
Renters Face Fierce Competition as Listing Times Shrink
Surge in Fake Science: 19 journals shut down due to fraudulent papers from 'paper mills'
Oh Happy Day Edwin Hawkins - Anthony Brown w FBCG Combined Choir
Global Birthrates Decline, Raising Economic and Social Concerns
'Stand by Me' performed by Karen Gibson and The Kingdom Choir
Boeing Faces Possible Prosecution Over 737 MAX Settlement Violation
National Anthem of the British Virgin Islands - Oh, Beautiful Virgin
Prisoner Escapes in France as Two Officers Killed in Van Ambush
Hello Dolly
German Court Rules AfD Can Be Monitored for Extremism
for KING & COUNTRY - Amen (Reborn) [feat. Lecrae & The WRLDFMS Tony Wi
Jacob Rees-Mogg Criticizes Bank of England’s Inflation Strategy
Bob Marley - Get Up Stand Up
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Promote Invictus Games in Nigeria
Yes He Can
UK Arms Ban on Israel Would Aid Hamas, Says Cameron
What A Friend We Have In Jesus
US Regulators Probe Credit Card Reward Schemes
Labour Vows to End Rwanda Deportation Scheme/Scam
Touch The Hem Of His Garment
Exonerated Andrew Malkinson Faces Hardship Awaiting Compensation
The Lord's Prayer
India Poised to Surpass Japan as 4th Largest Economy
UN General Assembly Approves Palestinian Membership Bid
Biden to Impose Tariffs on Chinese Electric Vehicles
Ray Charles And The Voices Of Jubilaton, Oh, Happy Day
Cyberattack Disrupts Major US Healthcare Network
Ramblin' Rose
McDonald's Introduces $5 Meal Deal to Attract Customers
Protoje - Who Knows ft. Chronixx
Protesters Attempt to Storm Tesla's German Factory
Pressure - Virgin Islands Nice
The United Kingdom reports it has emerged from recession
Phil Wickham - House Of The Lord
Teens Forming Friendships with AI Chatbots
My God Is Real (Yes, God Is Real)
WhatsApp Rolls Out Major Redesign
The Lion King Circle of Life by LEBO M. — LIVE at the HAVASI Symphonic
Neuralink's First Brain Implant Experiences Issue
Louis Armstrong - When The Saints Go Marching In
Apple Unveils New iPad Pro with M4 Chip, Misleading AI Claims
Kanye West Sunday Service - hallelujah, salvation, and glory
OpenAI to Announce Google Search Competitor
Jonathan Nelson - I Believe (Island Medley
Apple Apologizes for Controversial iPad Pro Ad Featuring Instrument Destruction
From The Virgin Islands Sqad Up
Japan Passes Law for Faster Removal of Online Defamation
Common, John Legend - Glory
Boeing 737 Catches Fire in Senegal, 10 Injured
Anthony Evans vs. Jesse Campbell - If I Ain't Got You
Cruise Ship Arrives in NYC with Dead 44-Foot Whale on Bow
I have a dream, MLK inspiring speech
Trump lawyer questions Stormy Daniels' account of sex with Trump
Aretha Franklin, Marvis Staples - Oh Happy Day
Hunter Biden's Gun Charges Upheld, Trial Set for June
BVI Freedom Song
Last Indian soldiers leave Maldives
Billy Preston - You Can't Beat God Giving (Live)
Brave English woman hilariously mocks a masked thief as he attempts to steal her bike.
UK General Election: Sunak Acknowledges Disappointing Results but Maintains Confidence
Oh Happy Day Edwin Hawkins - Anthony Brown w FBCG Combined Choir
Sword Attack Victim Henry De Los Rios Polonia Grateful for NHS Care
'Stand by Me' performed by Karen Gibson and The Kingdom Choir
Post Office Lawyer Jarnail Singh Faces Allegations of Lying About Software Bugs
National Anthem of the British Virgin Islands - Oh, Beautiful Virgin
Post Office Scandal: Expert Accused of Giving False Court Testimony
Hello Dolly
Suspended Tory Councillor Puts Essex Council Majority at Risk
for KING & COUNTRY - Amen (Reborn) [feat. Lecrae & The WRLDFMS Tony Wi
UK Government Loses Court Case Over Inadequate Climate Actions
Bob Marley - Get Up Stand Up
Apple Faces Significant Sales Decline Amid AI Integration Delay
Yes He Can
10,000 Black Cab Drivers Sue Uber for $313M Over Alleged Breach of London Booking Rules
What A Friend We Have In Jesus
Today’s headlines
Interns Investigate Unsafe UK Criminal Convictions
Touch The Hem Of His Garment
Contaminated Blood Inquiry Highlights Omitted Risks
The Lord's Prayer
Kwasi Kwarteng Criticizes Liz Truss as 'Trumpian'
SNP Overcomes Labour Confidence Motion
Study Finds Gender Health Gap in UK
Ray Charles And The Voices Of Jubilaton, Oh, Happy Day