Beautiful Virgin Islands

Friday, Dec 05, 2025

UK politicians and business people will be closely watching the extradition of Mike Lynch

UK politicians and business people will be closely watching the extradition of Mike Lynch

The founder of Autonomy, which was bought by HP, Dr Mike Lynch has fought extradition tooth and nail.
The extradition of Mike Lynch to the United States will undoubtedly alarm a number of British business people.

Dr Lynch faces charges over Autonomy, the software company he founded and which was bought by Hewlett Packard in 2011 for $11bn.

The US hardware maker subsequently wrote off $8bn of the purchase price and has accused Dr Lynch of manipulating Autonomy's accounts.

Central to Dr Lynch's attempt to avoid extradition was that Autonomy was a British company, listed on the London Stock Exchange, subject to British accounting rules and whose takeover was carried out under British takeover rules.

Therefore, they argued, the British courts were the place to hear such a case.

The UK courts found against him on the grounds that Autonomy had derived the majority of its sales in the US and that the losses incurred by HP had been suffered in the US and by American investors.

Unhelpfully for Dr Lynch, the UK's Serious Fraud Office had dropped its own investigation into the takeover in 2015, indicating the US was the most appropriate jurisdiction in which any such proceedings should take place.

The US authorities also argued that claims made by Dr Lynch about Autonomy's financial performance in phone calls and emails to HP's advisers and executives had broken US wire fraud law.

The implications for British business people, then, are that anyone who sells their business to a US buyer, who derives a proportion (however small) of their sales in the US, or whose shares are bought by a US investor, may be open to similar treatment if perceived of wrongdoing.

It is why Dr Lynch's MP, the Conservative Party chairman Greg Hands, has previously argued the existence of the treaty will deter entrepreneurship and deter some British businesses from selling interests to US investors.

Aggressively going after British business people

The US certainly has form in going after British business people aggressively.

Among the more notorious cases was that of Nigel Potter, the former chief executive of the gambling and dog track operator Wembley Group, who was jailed in 2005 for three years after being convicted on three counts of conspiring to commit wire fraud.

He was forced to serve his sentence in a high security prison because, as an "alien", he was deemed a flight risk.

Unlike Dr Lynch, who fought extradition tooth and nail, Mr Potter had travelled to the US voluntarily in an attempt to clear his name. The mild-mannered accountant even found himself being clapped in leg irons when undergoing cancer treatment.

Then there was Ian Norris, the former chief executive of Morgan Crucible, the industrial materials company.

He was accused by the US of conspiring to fix the price of car parts and avoided extradition when the House of Lords ruled he could not be convicted of the offences and, accordingly, not extradited.

The US then went after Mr Norris on a lesser charge of conspiring to obstruct a criminal antitrust inquiry - and ended up being jailed for 18 months.

Most famous were the so-called "NatWest Three" - Giles Darby, David Bermingham and Gary Mulgrew - who were convicted for wire fraud while working for NatWest and doing business for the crashed US energy trading group Enron.

Like Dr Lynch, they argued that, as British nationals working for a British bank and whose alleged offences took place in Britain, they should be tried in Britain.

The courts, again, disagreed.

Prior to their extradition, the three argued they would not receive a fair trial in the US, a concern also flagged by Dr Lynch and his supporters.

Mr Bermingham later wrote in The Times: "It is a near statistical certainty that someone extradited to the US will end up guilty, most probably through a plea bargain rather than going to trial, because the criminal justice system in the US is so heavily geared towards this outcome… a toxic combination of political machismo and judges who are political appointees produces a system where few sane people will run the risk of going to trial.

"Nearly 98% of people indicted in the federal system will plea bargain, because the penalties for losing at trial are so disproportionate."

There is also a suspicion that the case against Dr Lynch has been motivated by spite on the part of HP for the way it ended up overpaying for Autonomy.

Meg Whitman, the former chief executive under whom HP pursued civil charges against Mr Lynch, has gone on to pursue a career in politics and is currently the US ambassador to Kenya. It is easy to see how the US Department for Justice might be tempted to take up the cudgels on behalf of such a big, established US company.

The embarrassment for HP from the Autonomy deal is lasting - not least because, in the City, Dr Lynch was always quite a divisive figure.

Had HP done better due diligence when it acquired Autonomy, it would not have had to look very far to find analysts who had accused the company of fiddling its figures.

The political dimension

There is a broader dimension to the case, too.

Many MPs, among them the former Brexit secretary David Davis, the security minister Tom Tugendhat and the former Liberal Democrat leaders Sir Vince Cable and Sir Menzies Campbell, say Dr Lynch's case raises broader issues of UK sovereignty.

They argue that the extradition treaty between the UK and the US signed by the Blair government in 2003 is one-sided and that more Britons seem to be extradited to the US than the other way round.

That criticism has intensified in the wake of America's refusal to extradite the diplomat's wife Anne Sacoolas for causing the death of the British teenager Harry Dunn.

Politicians, then, will be watching closely to see what happens to Dr Lynch.

So, too, will many British business people.
Newsletter

Related Articles

Beautiful Virgin Islands
0:00
0:00
Close
India backs down on plan to mandate government “Sanchar Saathi” app on all smartphones
King Charles Welcomes German President Steinmeier to UK in First State Visit by Berlin in 27 Years
UK Plans Major Cutback to Jury Trials as Crown Court Backlog Nears 80,000
UK Government to Significantly Limit Jury Trials in England and Wales
U.S. and U.K. Seal Drug-Pricing Deal: Britain Agrees to Pay More, U.S. Lifts Tariffs
UK Postpones Decision Yet Again on China’s Proposed Mega-Embassy in London
Head of UK Budget Watchdog Resigns After Premature Leak of Reeves’ Budget Report
Car-sharing giant Zipcar to exit UK market by end of 2025
Reports of Widespread Drone Deployment Raise Privacy and Security Questions in the UK
UK Signals Security Concerns Over China While Pursuing Stronger Trade Links
Google warns of AI “irrationality” just as Gemini 3 launch rattles markets
Top Consultancies Freeze Starting Salaries as AI Threatens ‘Pyramid’ Model
Macron Says Washington Pressuring EU to Delay Enforcement of Digital-Regulation Probes Against Meta, TikTok and X
UK’s DragonFire Laser Downs High-Speed Drones as £316m Deal Speeds Naval Deployment
UK Chancellor Rejects Claims She Misled Public on Fiscal Outlook Ahead of Budget
Starmer Defends Autumn Budget as Finance Chief Faces Accusations of Misleading Public Finances
EU Firms Struggle with 3,000-Hour Paperwork Load — While Automakers Fear De Facto 2030 Petrol Car Ban
White House launches ‘Hall of Shame’ site to publicly condemn media outlets for alleged bias
UK Budget’s New EV Mileage Tax Undercuts Case for Plug-In Hybrids
UK Government Launches National Inquiry into ‘Grooming Gangs’ After US Warning and Rising Public Outcry
Taylor Swift Extends U.K. Chart Reign as ‘The Fate of Ophelia’ Hits Six Weeks at No. 1
250 Still Missing in the Massive Fire, 94 Killed. One Day After the Disaster: Survivor Rescued on the 16th Floor
Trump: National Guard Soldier Who Was Shot in Washington Has Died; Second Soldier Fighting for His Life
UK Chancellor Reeves Defends Tax Rises as Essential to Reduce Child Poverty and Stabilise Public Finances
No Evidence Found for Claim That UK Schools Are Shifting to Teaching American English
European Powers Urge Israel to Halt West Bank Settler Violence Amid Surge in Attacks
"I Would Have Given Her a Kidney": She Lent Bezos’s Ex-Wife $1,000 — and Received Millions in Return
European States Approve First-ever Military-Grade Surveillance Network via ESA
UK to Slash Key Pension Tax Perk, Targeting High Earners Under New Budget
UK Government Announces £150 Annual Cut to Household Energy Bills Through Levy Reforms
UK Court Hears Challenge to Ban on Palestine Action as Critics Decry Heavy-Handed Measures
Investors Rush Into UK Gilts and Sterling After Budget Eases Fiscal Concerns
UK to Raise Online Betting Taxes by £1.1 Billion Under New Budget — Firms Warn of Fallout
Lamine Yamal? The ‘Heir to Messi’ Lost to Barcelona — and the Kingdom Is in a Frenzy
Warner Music Group Drops Suit Against Suno, Launches Licensed AI-Music Deal
HP to Cut up to 6,000 Jobs Globally as It Ramps Up AI Integration
MediaWorld Sold iPad Air for €15 — Then Asked Customers to Return Them or Pay More
UK Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer Promises ‘Full-Time’ Education for All Children as School Attendance Slips
UK Extends Sugar Tax to Sweetened Milkshakes and Lattes in 2028 Health Push
UK Government Backs £49 Billion Plan for Heathrow Third Runway and Expansion
UK Gambling Firms Report £1bn Surge in Annual Profits as Pressure Mounts for Higher Betting Taxes
UK Shares Advance Ahead of Budget as Financials and Consumer Staples Lead Gains
Domino’s UK CEO Andrew Rennie Steps Down Amid Strategic Reset
UK Economy Stalls as Reeves Faces First Budget Test
UK Economy’s Weak Start Adds Pressure on Prime Minister Starmer
UK Government Acknowledges Billionaire Exodus Amid Tax Rise Concerns
UK Budget 2025: Markets Brace as Chancellor Faces Fiscal Tightrope
UK Unveils Strategic Plan to Secure Critical Mineral Supply Chains
UK Taskforce Calls for Radical Reset of Nuclear Regulation to Cut Costs and Accelerate Build
UK Government Launches Consultation on Major Overhaul of Settlement Rules
×