Beautiful Virgin Islands

Monday, Jan 19, 2026

How does an American impeachment trial work?

How does an American impeachment trial work?

The Senate sets its own rules. Milk is involved
LAST YEAR Donald Trump became the first American president to run for re-election after being impeached. On December 18th 2019 the House of Representatives voted along almost entirely partisan lines to impeach Mr Trump for abuse of power and obstruction of Congress.

On January 13th-one week after his supporters stormed the Capitol to prevent Congress from certifying his defeat, resulting in the deaths of five people, including a Capitol Police officer-he became the first president to be impeached twice.

Every House Democrat, along with ten Republicans, voted to impeach Mr Trump for “inciting violence against the government of the United States”, making it the most bipartisan presidential impeachment vote in American history. Mr Trump’s trial in the Senate begins on February 9th. How does the Senate conduct such a trial?

The fourth section of Article Two of the constitution says that a president can be impeached for “Treason, Bribery and other high Crimes and Misdemeanors”-a standard so vague that Gerald Ford, a former president, cynically but accurately noted that “an impeachable offence is whatever a majority of the House of Representatives considers it to be at a given moment in history.”

Grounds for impeachment may be vaguely and politically defined, but the first two articles of the Constitution lay out the basic procedure: the House has the sole power to impeach; the Senate conducts the trial; conviction requires the votes of two-thirds of the senators; punishment is limited to removal from office and a bar on standing again; and when a president stands trial (any federal officer, not just presidents, can be impeached; most of the 20 impeachment trials have been of judges), the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court must preside.

But the mechanics of the trial are entirely up to the Senate. That is why, for instance, its starting date was subject to negotiation between Charles Schumer and Mitch McConnell, respectively the Senate’s current and former majority leaders. According to rules proposed in 1974 and adopted in 1986, senators are sworn in as jurors, but they can also call witnesses, under subpoena if necessary, and question them by submitting written queries to the presiding officer.

As in a standard trial, the House managers presenting the case for impeachment and the lawyers defending the impeached person make opening and closing statements, with the House managers speaking first in the former case and last in the latter. In this trial, they plan to rely heavily on video presentations rather than witness testimony.

Debates on procedural matters cannot exceed two hours in total (in contrast to the chamber’s customary practice of limitless debate), and that time must be evenly divided between the two sides.

The trial is, of course, public, but the Senate can retreat into a closed deliberative session on proposal by one senator and seconding by another, during which each senator may speak for ten minutes each on most questions, and 15 on “the final question”-whether the impeached person is guilty or innocent. For obscure reasons, senators may drink only water or sparkling water, provided by the Senate cloakroom, or milk, which they must provide themselves.

In Mr Trump’s trial, however, one senator will combine his role as juror with a more prominent role. Rather than the chief justice, Patrick Leahy of Vermont, the president pro tempore of the Senate (the longest-serving member of the majority party), will preside, as is customary for non-presidential impeachments. That no doubt will delight Chief Justice John Roberts, an institutionalist who is wary of the Court being drawn into politics, and reportedly did not want to preside over another impeachment trial.

That is not the only unusual thing about the trial. It will be the first of a president who has left office. Mr Trump’s attorneys argue, in a brief filed to the Senate on February 2nd, that his no longer holding office renders the impeachment process illegitimate. History suggests a different view-the Senate tried William Belknap, a former secretary of war, after he left office. But the presidents' lawyers will probably still lean heavily on this question.

Late last month, 45 of the 50 Republican senators backed a motion from Rand Paul of Kentucky asserting the unconstitutionality of the proceeding. That will no doubt frustrate Democrats, some of whom have mooted another measure arguing that the 14th amendment-which bars any federal elected official who engaged in “insurrection or rebellion” against the government from holding office-bars Mr Trump from running for president again.

But Mr Trump and his supporters would almost certainly challenge such a measure in court. It also carries political risks, not least letting Mr Trump cast himself as a silenced martyr, rather than what the record shows he is-a defeated one-term president.
Newsletter

Related Articles

Beautiful Virgin Islands
0:00
0:00
Close
High-Speed Train Collision in Southern Spain Kills at Least Twenty-One and Injures Scores
Meghan Markle May Return to the U.K. This Summer as Security Review Advances
Trump’s Greenland Tariff Threat Sparks EU Response and Risks Deep Transatlantic Rift
Prince Harry’s High Court Battle With Daily Mail Publisher Begins in London
Trump’s Tariff Escalation Presents Complex Challenges for the UK Economy
UK Prime Minister Starmer Rebukes Trump’s Greenland Tariff Strategy as Transatlantic Tensions Rise
Prince Harry’s Last Press Case in UK Court Signals Potential Turning Point in Media and Royal Relations
OpenAI to Begin Advertising in ChatGPT in Strategic Shift to New Revenue Model
GDP Growth Remains the Most Telling Barometer of Britain’s Economic Health
Prince William and Kate Middleton Stay Away as Prince Harry Visits London Amid Lingering Rift
Britain Braces for Colder Weather and Snow Risk as Temperatures Set to Plunge
Mass Protests Erupt as UK Nears Decision on China’s ‘Mega Embassy’ in London
Prince Harry to Return to UK to Testify in High-Profile Media Trial Against Associated Newspapers
Keir Starmer Rejects Trump’s Greenland Tariff Threat as ‘Completely Wrong’
Trump to hit Europe with 10% tariffs until Greenland deal is agreed
Prince Harry Returns to UK High Court as Final Privacy Trial Against Daily Mail Publisher Begins
Britain Confronts a Billion-Pound Wind Energy Paradox Amid Grid Constraints
The graduate 'jobpocalypse': Entry-level jobs are not shrinking. They are disappearing.
Cybercrime, Inc.: When Crime Becomes an Economy. How the World Accidentally Built a Twenty-Trillion-Dollar Criminal Economy
The Return of the Hands: Why the AI Age Is Rewriting the Meaning of “Real Work”
UK PM Kier Scammer Ridicules Tories With "Kamasutra"
Strategic Restraint, Credible Force, and the Discipline of Power
United Kingdom and Norway Endorse NATO’s ‘Arctic Sentry’ Mission Including Greenland
Woman Claiming to Be Freddie Mercury’s Secret Daughter Dies at Forty-Eight After Rare Cancer Battle
UK Launches First-Ever ‘Town of Culture’ Competition to Celebrate Local Stories and Boost Communities
Planned Sale of Shell and Exxon’s UK Gas Assets to Viaro Energy Collapses Amid Regulatory and Market Hurdles
UK Intensifies Arctic Security Engagement as Trump’s Greenland Rhetoric Fuels Allied Concern
Meghan Markle Could Return to the UK for the First Time in Nearly Four Years If Security Is Secured
Meghan Markle Likely to Return to UK Only if Harry Secures Official Security Cover
UAE Restricts Funding for Emiratis to Study in UK Amid Fears Over Muslim Brotherhood Influence
EU Seeks ‘Farage Clause’ in Brexit Reset Talks to Safeguard Long-Term Agreement Stability
Starmer’s Push to Rally Support for Action Against Elon Musk’s X Faces Setback as Canada Shuns Ban
UK Free School Meals Expansion Faces Political and Budgetary Delays
EU Seeks ‘Farage Clause’ in Brexit Reset Talks With Britain
Germany Hit by Major Airport Strikes Disrupting European Travel
Prince Harry Seeks King Charles’ Support to Open Invictus Games on UK Return
Washington Holds Back as Britain and France Signal Willingness to Deploy Troops in Postwar Ukraine
Elon Musk Accuses UK Government of Suppressing Free Speech as X Faces Potential Ban Over AI-Generated Content
Russia Deploys Hypersonic Missile in Strike on Ukraine
OpenAI and SoftBank Commit One Billion Dollars to Energy and Data Centre Supplier
UK Prime Minister Starmer Reaffirms Support for Danish Sovereignty Over Greenland Amid U.S. Pressure
UK Support Bolsters U.S. Seizure of Russian-Flagged Tanker Marinera in Atlantic Strike on Sanctions Evasion
The Claim That Maduro’s Capture and Trial Violate International Law Is Either Legally Illiterate—or Deliberately Deceptive
UK Data Watchdog Probes Elon Musk’s X Over AI-Generated Grok Images Amid Surge in Non-Consensual Outputs
Prince Harry to Return to UK for Court Hearing Without Plans to Meet King Charles III
UK Confirms Support for US Seizure of Russian-Flagged Oil Tanker in North Atlantic
Béla Tarr, Visionary Hungarian Filmmaker, Dies at Seventy After Long Illness
UK and France Pledge Military Hubs Across Ukraine in Post-Ceasefire Security Plan
Prince Harry Poised to Regain UK Security Cover, Clearing Way for Family Visits
UK Junk Food Advertising Ban Faces Major Loophole Allowing Brand-Only Promotions
×