Beautiful Virgin Islands

Thursday, Jan 22, 2026

U.S. Supreme Court justices want to ‘fix’ historic same-sex marriage ruling so religious bigots can ‘participate in society’

U.S. Supreme Court justices want to ‘fix’ historic same-sex marriage ruling so religious bigots can ‘participate in society’

Two Supreme Court justices have suggested that the court needs to “fix” Obergefell v Hodges, the case that made same-sex marriage the law of the land.
In October, the court decided not to hear a case involving Kim Davis, the Kentucky clerk who has been sued for refusing to issue marriage licences to same-sex couples because of her religious beliefs.

The Supreme Court opted not to take the case, leaving in place a decision from a lower court that allowed a lawsuit against Davis to proceed.

However, justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito released a joint statement saying that, while they agreed with the decision not to hear the case, Davis’ legal issues should serve as a “stark reminder of the consequences” the 2015 ruling on same-sex marriage was having on religious liberty.

In their statement, the justices said the Supreme Court had “read a right to same-sex marriage into the Fourteenth Amendment, even though that right is nowhere in the text”.

They said that several members of the court noted the decision would threaten the religious liberty of those who believe that marriage is “a sacred institution between one man and one woman”.

Thomas and Alito went on to argue that same-sex marriage should have been legalised through Congress or by individual states, which could, they suggested, have paved the way for exemptions for people who don’t agree with same-sex marriage.

They hit out at their fellow Supreme Court justices for bypassing the “democratic process” with its 2015 ruling, which resulted in same-sex marriage become a reality across the United States.

The justices said the 2015 ruling had allowed governments, employers and schools to “vilify” those who have religious beliefs, branding them “bigots”.

“Those predictions did not take long to become reality,” they added.

“Kim Davis, a former county clerk in the Commonwealth of Kentucky, was responsible for authorising marriage licences. Davis is also a devout Christian. When she began her tenure as clerk, Davis’ sincerely held religious beliefs – that marriage exists between one man and one woman – corresponded with the definition of marriage under Kentucky law.

“Within weeks of this court granting certiorari in Obergefell, Davis began lobbying for amendments to Kentucky law that would protect the free exercise rights of those who had religious objections to same-sex marriage. But those efforts were cut short by this court’s decision in Obergefell.”

The Supreme Court judges pinned Davis’ plight on Obergefell, saying she “found herself faced with a choice between her religious beliefs and her job”.

“When she chose to follow her faith, and without any statutory protection of her religious beliefs, she was sued almost immediately for violating the constitutional rights of same-sex couples.”

They described Davis as “one of the first victims” of the court’s “cavalier treatment of religion” in its ruling on Obergefell.

“Due to Obergefell, those with sincerely held religious beliefs concerning marriage will find it increasingly difficult to participate in society without running afoul of Obergefell and its effect on other anti-discrimination laws.”

Thomas and Alito went on to argue that the Supreme Court had “forced” same-sex marriage on society “through its creation of atextual constitutional rights” and had left “those with religious objections in the lurch”.

The justices closed out their statement by saying Davis’ case “implicates important questions about the scope of our decision in Obergefell”.

“By choosing to privilege a novel constitutional right over the religious liberty interests explicitly protected in the First Amendment, and by doing so undemocratically ,the court has created a problem that only it can fix.

“Until then, Obergefell will continue to have ‘ruinous consequences for religious liberty’.”

Their statement was released shortly before Amy Coney Barrett was confirmed to the Supreme Court in a devastating blow to LGBT+ people.

The appointment of the anti-LGBT+ Roman Catholic judge has tipped the Supreme Court to leaning heavily conservative, with many queer people afraid that their hard-won rights – such as same-sex marriage – could come under threat as a result.
Newsletter

Related Articles

Beautiful Virgin Islands
0:00
0:00
Close
Prince William to Make Official Visit to Saudi Arabia in February
Prince Harry Breaks Down in London Court, Says UK Tabloids Have Made Meghan Markle’s Life ‘Absolute Misery’
Malin + Goetz UK Business Enters Administration, All Stores Close
EU and UK Reject Trump’s Greenland-Linked Tariff Threats and Pledge Unified Response
UK Deepfake Crackdown Puts Intense Pressure on Musk’s Grok AI After Surge in Non-Consensual Explicit Images
Prince Harry Becomes Emotional in London Court, Invokes Memory of Princess Diana in Testimony Against UK Tabloids
UK Inflation Rises Unexpectedly but Interest Rate Cuts Still Seen as Likely
Starmer Steps Back from Trump’s ‘Board of Peace’ Amid Strained US–UK Relations
Prince Harry’s Lawyer Tells UK Court Daily Mail Was Complicit in Unlawful Privacy Invasions
UK Government Approves China’s ‘Mega Embassy’ in London Amid Debate Over Security and Diplomacy
Trump Cites UK’s Chagos Islands Sovereignty Shift as Justification for Pursuing Greenland Acquisition
UK Government Weighs Australia-Style Social Media Ban for Under-Sixteens Amid Rising Concern Over Online Harm
Trump Aides Say U.S. Has Discussed Offering Asylum to British Jews Amid Growing Antisemitism Concerns
UK Seeks Diplomatic De-escalation with Trump Over Greenland Tariff Threat
Prince Harry Returns to London as High Court Trial Begins Over Alleged Illegal Tabloid Snooping
High-Speed Train Collision in Southern Spain Kills at Least Twenty-One and Injures Scores
Meghan Markle May Return to the U.K. This Summer as Security Review Advances
Trump’s Greenland Tariff Threat Sparks EU Response and Risks Deep Transatlantic Rift
Prince Harry’s High Court Battle With Daily Mail Publisher Begins in London
Trump’s Tariff Escalation Presents Complex Challenges for the UK Economy
UK Prime Minister Starmer Rebukes Trump’s Greenland Tariff Strategy as Transatlantic Tensions Rise
Prince Harry’s Last Press Case in UK Court Signals Potential Turning Point in Media and Royal Relations
OpenAI to Begin Advertising in ChatGPT in Strategic Shift to New Revenue Model
GDP Growth Remains the Most Telling Barometer of Britain’s Economic Health
Prince William and Kate Middleton Stay Away as Prince Harry Visits London Amid Lingering Rift
Britain Braces for Colder Weather and Snow Risk as Temperatures Set to Plunge
Mass Protests Erupt as UK Nears Decision on China’s ‘Mega Embassy’ in London
Prince Harry to Return to UK to Testify in High-Profile Media Trial Against Associated Newspapers
Keir Starmer Rejects Trump’s Greenland Tariff Threat as ‘Completely Wrong’
Trump to hit Europe with 10% tariffs until Greenland deal is agreed
Prince Harry Returns to UK High Court as Final Privacy Trial Against Daily Mail Publisher Begins
Britain Confronts a Billion-Pound Wind Energy Paradox Amid Grid Constraints
The graduate 'jobpocalypse': Entry-level jobs are not shrinking. They are disappearing.
Cybercrime, Inc.: When Crime Becomes an Economy. How the World Accidentally Built a Twenty-Trillion-Dollar Criminal Economy
The Return of the Hands: Why the AI Age Is Rewriting the Meaning of “Real Work”
UK PM Kier Scammer Ridicules Tories With "Kamasutra"
Strategic Restraint, Credible Force, and the Discipline of Power
United Kingdom and Norway Endorse NATO’s ‘Arctic Sentry’ Mission Including Greenland
Woman Claiming to Be Freddie Mercury’s Secret Daughter Dies at Forty-Eight After Rare Cancer Battle
UK Launches First-Ever ‘Town of Culture’ Competition to Celebrate Local Stories and Boost Communities
Planned Sale of Shell and Exxon’s UK Gas Assets to Viaro Energy Collapses Amid Regulatory and Market Hurdles
UK Intensifies Arctic Security Engagement as Trump’s Greenland Rhetoric Fuels Allied Concern
Meghan Markle Could Return to the UK for the First Time in Nearly Four Years If Security Is Secured
Meghan Markle Likely to Return to UK Only if Harry Secures Official Security Cover
UAE Restricts Funding for Emiratis to Study in UK Amid Fears Over Muslim Brotherhood Influence
EU Seeks ‘Farage Clause’ in Brexit Reset Talks to Safeguard Long-Term Agreement Stability
Starmer’s Push to Rally Support for Action Against Elon Musk’s X Faces Setback as Canada Shuns Ban
UK Free School Meals Expansion Faces Political and Budgetary Delays
EU Seeks ‘Farage Clause’ in Brexit Reset Talks With Britain
Germany Hit by Major Airport Strikes Disrupting European Travel
×